Wedding Pricing & Flavors

Don’t see what you’re looking for?  Just ask!

Cake Flavor Suggestions

Classic: Almond, Vanilla, Chocolate, Dark Chocolate, Funfetti, Red Velvet, Strawberry, and Lemon.

Deluxe: Amaretto, Apple, Banana, Blueberry, Black Bottom, Bourbon Chocolate, Caramel, Carrot, Cherry Chip, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Cinnamon, Coconut, Cookies n Cream, Chocolate Kahlua, Chocolate Guinness, Key Lime, Lavender, Marble, German Chocolate, Gingerbread, Orange Creamsicle, Peach, Peanut Butter, Pineapple, Pistachio, Pumpkin Spice, Pumpkin Caramel, Pink Champagne, S’mores, Spice, White Chocolate, and more… Add $0.25/serving.
Gluten-free (most favors available) …. Add $0.75/serving. Vegan or Sugar-free flavors (available in classic flavors except funfetti)… Add $1/serving. Other gourmet and custom flavors are available upon request.

Frosting Suggestions

Classic Buttercreams: Our Signature Almond, Vanilla, or Chocolate Buttercream

Deluxe Buttercreams: Peanut Butter, Caramel, Coconut, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Strawberry, Coffee, Raspberry, Lemon, Hazelnut, Irish Cream, Cinnamon, Mint, Marshmallow, Honey, Cherry … Add $0.25/serving.

Premium Frostings: Cream Cheese, German Chocolate, and Chocolate Ganache … Add $0.75/serving.
Fondant … Add $2.00/ serving.

Filling Suggestions

Classic: Our Signature Almond, Vanilla, or Chocolate Buttercream (Additional $0.25 for cupcakes)

Deluxe Fillings: Deluxe Buttercreams… Add $0.25

Premium Fillings: Strawberry Preserves, Raspberry Preserves, Lemon Filling, Ganache, Bavarian Cream, Fresh Fruit, German Chocolate, and Cream Cheese … Add $0.50/serving.

Can’t decide on a flavor combination? Choose from our Signature Flavors

Cake and Cupcake Starting Prices

Tiered Cakes – Two layer stacked cakes … $4.60/ serving
(Faux/styrofoam tiers receive a 25% serving discount. This is a good option for customers who want a larger cake than the number of servings they need. However, combining faux tiers and kitchen cakes is more expensive than typical tiered cakes and is not a cost saving option.)

Layer Cakes – Individual two layer cakes … $3.25/ serving. 6” Sweetheart cake starts at $39.

Kitchen Cakes – Two layer cakes to provide additional servings, not displayed… $2.50/ serving

Wedding Cupcakes – $3 per cupcake (regular), $2 per cupcake (mini). Cupcake and cake stands are available for rent or purchase in various sizes and styles.

Cheesecakes – Available sheet, tiered, or bite size… 6” ($32, serves 6), 8” ($49, serves 10), 9” ($55, serves 12), and 11” ($69, serves 16). Bite-size $28/dozen. Add $2/serving for tiered cheesecakes.

Bite-Size Dessert Bar Options

An assortment of bite size desserts is perfect for weddings in which the couple may not prefer traditional cake or as an addition to your tiered cake or cupcakes. We recommend 2-4 bites per guest. Prices below are starting prices for individual bite size pieces (approximately 1-2″). Optionally displayed in a cupcake liner for $10 per 100 bites. Size, flavor, décor and quantity determine the final price. 2 dozen minimum per flavor/item. If you don’t see what you are looking for? Just ask!

Brownies– Powdered Sugar Chocolate Fudge …$10/dozen.
Chocolate drizzle, Raspberry swirl, Strawberry swirl, Cream Cheese swirl, Caramel swirl, Peanut Butter swirl, and more… $12/dozen.

Cookies– Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter, Molasses, Snicker Doodle, Red Velvet Crinkle …$10/dozen.
Pumpkin, Oatmeal Raisin, White Chocolate Macadamia Nut, Uniced Sugar Cookies … $12/dozen. Snowballs and Frosted Sugar Cookies $15/dozen.

Cheesecake Bites– NY Style … $28/dozen. NY Style with Strawberry drizzle, Raspberry drizzle, Caramel drizzle, Ganache drizzle … $30/dozen. Cherry topping … $32/dozen. Individual and tiered whole cheesecakes also available.

Chocolate Covered Strawberries– Semi-sweet or white chocolate with drizzle … $32/ dozen

Cake Balls and Pops– Crumbled cake rolled and dipped in chocolate. Many options available… $39/dozen.

Buckeyes– Traditional Chocolate, Peanut Butter OHIO treat … $10/dozen.

Chocolate Pretzels – Pretzel rods dipped in white or semi-sweet chocolate with sprinkles or drizzle … $21/dozen.

French Macarons– Almond meringue cookies (gluten-free!) with filling. Many flavors and colors available…  $27/dozen. (Minimum 2 dozen per flavor, $10 additional per custom color shell)

Rice Crispy Bites – Traditional bite size rice crispy treats with your choice of chocolate drizzle … $15/dozen.

Fruit Tarts – Sugar cookie “pie” shells are filled with a pudding cream and topped with fresh fruit … $36/dozen. Large $4.95 each.

Looking for edible wedding favors?  We’ve got you covered! Pick your favorite dessert and have names, dates, or even a picture placed on a festive and delicious gift for your guests. Individual packaging available or provide your own! Individually wrapped sugar cookies with a ribbon start at $4.50 each and individually wrapped two pack of buckeyes for $2.50 each. 

Pricing as of 6.2022 – subject to change without notice.

Wedding Home Page