Wedding Pricing & Flavors

Cake Flavor Suggestions

Traditional:   Almond, Chocolate, Dark Chocolate, Lemon, Red Velvet, Orange, Strawberry, and Vanilla.

Gourmet :  Amaretto, Banana, Blueberry, Black Bottom, Caramel, Carrot, Cherry Chip, Coconut, Cookies n Cream, Chocolate Kahlua, Chocolate Guinness, Key Lime, German Chocolate, Gingerbread, Peanut Butter, Pineapple, Pistachio, Pumpkin Spice, Pumpkin Caramel, Pink Champagne, S’mores, Spice, and more…  Add $0.25/serving. Vegan or Gluten-free flavors available… Add $1/serving.  Other gourmet and custom flavors are available.

Frosting Suggestions

Traditional:   Our Signature Almond, Vanilla, or Chocolate Buttercream

Gourmet:  Peanut Butter, Caramel, Coconut, Strawberry, Coffee, Raspberry, Lemon, Hazelnut, Irish Cream, Cinnamon, Mint, Marshmallow, Cherry and more… Add $0.25/serving.  Cream Cheese and Chocolate Ganache … Add $0.50/serving.  Fondant … Add, $2.00/ serving. Additional gourmet and custom flavors are available. Frostings are also available as fillings.

Filling Suggestions

Traditional:  Our Signature Almond, Vanilla, or Chocolate Buttercream

Gourmet:   Strawberry Preserves, Raspberry Preserves, Lemon Curd, Ganache, and Cream Cheese … Add $0.50/serving.
Seasonal fresh fruit and other gourmet and custom fillings available.

Cake and Cupcake Starting Prices 8/17

Tiered Cakes – Two layer stacked cakes … $4.00/ serving

(Faux/styrofoam tiers are 75% cost of real cake. FYI: This is a good option for customers who want a large cake, but have a small guest count and want a cake that is physically larger than the number of servings they need.  Combining faux tiers and kitchen cakes is more expensive than typical tiered cakes and is not suggested as a cost saving option.)

Layer/ Sweetheart Cakes – Individual two layer, displayed cakes … $3.00/ serving

Kitchen Cakes – Two layer cakes to provide additional servings, not displayed… $2.50/ serving

Wedding Cupcakes – $2.50 per cupcake (regular), $1.75 per cupcake (mini).  Orders with 200 or more cupcakes and stand rental receive a 5% discount.  Cupcake and cake stands are available for rent or purchase in various sizes and styles.

Our CupCake Bar – Are you looking for a one of a kind reception experience for your guests?  Ask us about our unique CupCake Bar where your guests can choose and create their own dessert. Starting at $3.00 per cupcake.

Cheesecakes – A popular option for customers who “don’t like cake,” optionally topped with cream cheese frosting. Available sheet, tiered, or bite size… 6” ($25, serves 6), 8” ($39, serves 10), 9” ($45, serves 12), and 11” ($59, serves 16). Add $1/serving for tiered cheesecakes.

Rental Cakes – Ask us about our new tiered cakes available for rental. We can even prepare a real top tier cake for you to cut!

Dessert Bar Options

The newest trend for wedding desserts!  An assortment of regular and bite size desserts are perfect for weddings in which the couple may not prefer traditional cake or as an addition to your tiered cake or cupcakes.  Prices below are starting prices for individual bite size pieces (approximately 1-2″).  Optionally displayed in a cupcake liner for $10 per 100 bites. Size, flavor, décor and quantity determine the final price.

If you don’t see what you are looking for? Just ask!

Brownies – Powdered Sugar Chocolate Fudge …$7.50/dozen.
Raspberry swirl, Strawberry swirl, Cream Cheese swirl, Caramel swirl, Peanut Butter swirl, and more… $9/dozen.

Cookies – Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter, Molasses, Snicker Doodle, Red Velvet Crinkle … $8/dozen.
Pumpkin, Oatmeal Raisin, White Chocolate Macadamia Nut, Rocky Road, Uniced Sugar Cookies … $10/dozen. Snowballs and Frosted Sugar Cookies $12/dozen.

Cheesecake Bites – NY Style … $24/dozen. Chocolate and Pumpkin … $27/dozen.
NY Style with Strawberry swirl, Raspberry swirl, Caramel swirl, Ganache drizzle … $26/dozen.
Individual and tiered whole cheesecakes also available.

Chocolate Covered Strawberries – Semi-sweet or white chocolate with drizzle … $21/dozen (in season).

Cake Balls and Pops – Crumbled cake rolled and dipped in chocolate. Many options available… $36/dozen.

Buckeyes – Traditional Chocolate, Peanut Butter OHIO treat … $10/dozen.

Chocolate Pretzels – Pretzel rods dipped in white or semi-sweet chocolate with sprinkles or drizzle … $12/dozen.

French Macarons – Meringue cookies (gluten-free!) with filling. Many flavors and colors available…  $24/dozen.

Fruit Tarts – Sugar cookie “pie” shells are filled with a pudding cream and topped with fresh fruit … $30/dozen.

Looking for edible wedding favors? We’ve got you covered! Pick your favorite dessert and have names, dates, or even a picture placed on a festive and delicious gift for your guests. Individual packaging available or provide your own! Individually wrapped sugar cookies with a ribbon start at $3.75 each.

Wedding Home Page