Custom Order Options

You imagine it; We create it!

We are a custom order business which means we do not have a strict menu. We are able to accommodate any cake or icing flavor you can dream up! We are also willing to help with any decoration or theme you request. We offer the following items on a regular basis. Want something you don’t see here? Give us a call and let us show you what we can do for you!

Bakery Bites Sampler Platter:

Dessert platter includes mini cupcakes, bite sized cookies, and bite sized brownies in a pastry box. Plastic trays with lids available for an additional $5-10. Great for corporate events and holiday parties.

3 dozen bakery bites assortment – $35
Buckeye Tailgate Platter: 3 dozen bakery bites assortment plus a dozen buckeyes – $40
6 dozen bakery bites assortment – $65
8 dozen bakery bites assortment – $85

Cookies, Brownies, and More:

We offer decorated cut out sugar cookies and many other seasonal cookies including (but not limited to) chocolate chip, peanut butter, molasses, and snickerdoodle. We can also offer other treats like brownies, buckeyes, and macaroons.  Cookie cakes and brownie cakes available as well!

3″ Seasonal Cookies start at $1.95 each.
3″ Cut out Sugar Cookies start at $2.50 each. Price dependent on size, icing flavor, and design.
Brownies Triangles start at $1.95 each.
Cookie and Brownie cakes start at $20.

Buckeyes – $0.75 each
Petite French Macaroons – $1.95 each. Many flavors and colors available. These delicious bites are also naturally gluten-free!

Looking for more bite size dessert options?? Check out our bakery bites platter!


New York Style Cheesecake with a Graham cracker crust.

8″ Round (Serves 12) – $32
10″ Round (Serves 20) – $48

Raspberry or Strawberry Swirl – Add $5
Pumpkin or Chocolate Cheesecake – Add $8
Turtle (Caramel Swirl, Peanuts, and Chocolate Chips) – Add $10

Cakes, Cupcakes, and Cake Balls or Pops:

1. Which desserts would you like at your special event?

Cupcakes with sprinkles and sparkles start at:

Mini – $1.75 each or $20.00 per dozen (dozen minimum)
Regular – $2.50 each or $27.00 per dozen
King – $4.25 each or $48 per dozen

Gluten free, Vegan, and Sugar Free cupcakes starting prices:
Mini – $2.50 or $27.00 per dozen
Regular – $3.75 or $42.00 per dozen
King – $5.50 or $63.00 per dozen
*** We try to keep vegan and gluten-free cupcakes in stock at the the shop, but preorders are highly recommended.  Quantity minimums may apply.

Layer, sheet, and cupcake cakes start at $25-28.
Tiered cakes start at $4 per serving.
2-D Sculpted cakes start at $3.00 per serving or $45 minimum.
3-D Sculpted cakes start at $7.00 per serving or $150 minimum.
3-D Fondant covered cakes start at $10.00 per serving.

Cake balls start at $2.50 each. These treats come on cupcake liner. (minimum dozen per flavor)
Cake pops start at $3 each. These treats come on a stick. (minimum dozen per flavor)
Bags and ribbons are an additional $1 per treat.

2. How many servings do you need for your event or special occasion?

3. What cake flavor(s) do you want?* These flavors are available everyday at our shop. Can’t decide? Take a look at some of our favorites, also available daily

  • Vanilla
  • Red Velvet
  • Almond
  • Lemon
  • Strawberry
  • Chocolate
  • Dark Chocolate
Additional charges and quantity minimums may apply to the following gourmet options*:
  • Amaretto
  • Apple
  • Spice
  • Caramel
  • Banana
  • Black Bottom (Chocolate cupcake with cream cheese and mini chocolate chips baked into the batter)
  • Carrot
  • Cherry Chip
  • Chocolate Guinness
  • Chocolate Kahlua
  • Coconut
  • Cookies ‘n Cream
  • German Chocolate
  • Gingerbread
  • Key Lime
  • Marble
  • Pineapple
  • Pink Champagne
  • Pistachio
  • Pumpkin Caramel
  • Pumpkin Spice
  • S’mores
  • Low-sugar, sugar-free, vegan, and gluten-free (Additional $1.00 per serving)

4. What icing flavor do you want?*

  • Signature Butter Cream (made with Real Vanilla and Almond Extract)
  • Vanilla Butter Cream (made with Real Vanilla)
  • Chocolate Butter Cream

Additional Charges apply to the following gourmet options*:

  • German Chocolate
  • Ganache
  • Cream Cheese
  • Whipped Cream
  • Whipped Butter Cream
  • Rolled Fondant
  • Flavored Butter Creams (Caramel, Coffee, Irish Cream, Raspberry, Strawberry, Lemon, Mint, Peanut Butter, Cotton Candy, Hazelnut, and MORE…)

5. Do you want your cake or cupcakes filled?* (additional charge)

  • Butter Cream Icings
  • Strawberry preserves
  • Raspberry preserves
  • Caramel sauce
  • Lemon Curd
  • Lime Curd
  • Vanilla Cream
  • Cream Cheese with chocolate chips
  • Ganache

6. How do you want it decorated?**

  • Sprinkles, colored icing and message written on the cake
  • Flowers, royal icing decorations, fondont decorations, candy, etc.
  • Custom designs created out of icing
  • Photographs or other electronic images
  • See our pictures or come in for more ideas!

7. Call us or stop in to place your order. We accept, cash, check, and credit cards. Payment, or a 50% non-refundable deposit, is expected when the order is placed. If an order must be cancelled, the deposit will be returned in the form of store credit, which can be applied to a future order. Orders may be rescheduled at the discretion of Our CupCakery.

  • We deliver, including OSU! Minimum delivery charge is $20 with an additional $1 per mile roundtrip outside that area.

*These are suggestions, many other options are available.

** Licensed and trademarked images may be purchased due to copyright infringement. Please visit DecoPac for ideas.

To see custom wedding cake options, visit our Wedding Page. The prices listed above are not applicable to wedding orders.